Showing posts with label taxes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label taxes. Show all posts

Friday, November 2, 2012

I've Found a New Toy...

Here's an interesting application from the committee for a Responsible Federal Budget that lets you simulate different corporate tax rates by eliminating/ keeping various corporate tax deductions and setting a revenue target. It's pretty fun, and illustrates the insane difficulty of getting the corporate tax system right.

http://crfb.org/corporate/

Tuesday, September 25, 2012

Teams with Plans, not Men with Cred

As with any presidential election, the decision between President Obama and Mitt Romney ultimately comes down not to which man is more suited to the office but to what team they will bring in to conduct policy. And the spoils of the general election go to the candidate who convinces the American electorate that their team will deliver them the goods. Obama's message in 2008 that he would make Americans richer with infastructure spending, education support and more progressive taxation trumped John McCain's attempt to run on his military and service credentials. In 2000, Bush's calls to redistribute the budget surplus in the form of tax cuts overcame Gore's message of... okay, bad example.

Americans in 2012 must evaluate the different promises made by the Obama and Romney team, not just the personal gravitas or experience each man may or may not have. We have a rather clear idea of what Obama's plan will entail; thats the benefit of being the incumbant. We can expect continued investments in public infrastructure, an open but cautious stance toward international trade, and perhaps increased spending on scientific research and subsidies for new engery industries. If Obama moves on taxes at all, we can expect him to allow the Bush tax cuts to expire, which would boost top marginal rates slightly. As far as the Federal Reserve, Bernanke and Co. are likely to stay in place, and that crowd seems to be moving in the direction of NGDP targeting, or at least likely to remain sympathetic to accomodative monetary policy as labor and capital markets stay slack. 

We have to distill Team Romney's plan from what he has claimed on the campaign trail, the history of his running mate's plans, and the opinions of his closest economic advisors. From that, we can predict reduced spending on infrastructure, reduced spending on scientific research and alternative energy subsidies, and a combative stance on international trade. In tandem, Romney would slash taxes by reducing capital taxes and marginal tax rates across the spectrum. As far as monetary policy, its widley expected that Romney would replace Bernanke with advisor John Taylor at the first chance. This would mean a change in the stance of monetary policy away from NGDP targeting and expansion and toward a tightening intended to raise the Fed funds rate to the level determined by Taylor's own Taylor Rule. 

As a caveat applied to both teams, I highly doubt either approach will be successful in closing the long-term budget deficit. I say that because despite the posturing, neither side has given a comprehensive or coherent plan for dealing with the driver of those deficits, Medicare.

Friday, September 7, 2012

John Cochrane for Treasury Secretary

I remember seeing this a while back and wondering who would best replace Geithner at Treasury, should Obama win and Geithner decide to leave. Recently I came across an old blog post by John Cochrane in which he laid out a series of proposals to finance the Federal debt that I find absolutely compelling.

Lets take a listen:

"I don't know who in their right mind is lending the US government money for 10 years at 1.59% and for thirty years at 2.67%. You have to believe inflation will be lower than these values just to get your money back, let alone make any real return.  (The best I can do is to opine that these are not long-term investors, and they think they can get out before rates rise. I will admit that understanding such low rates is stretching my rational-investor efficient-market prejudices.)

Well, no matter. When offered a screaming good deal, you should take it!

Restructuring US debt to longer maturities has all sorts of advantages. (Restructuring. I am not advocating stimulus!) It buys lots of insurance, very cheaply.

Think about what happens with very long term debt vs. rolling over one or two year debt, which is what the US does now.  Sooner or later, interest rates will surely rise to normal, 5-6%. If we are rolling over debt, that means the US Treasury has to come up with an extra 4-5% times the outstanding stock of debt, each year, to pay interest. 5% of $15 trillion is $750 billion, more than half our current (and already unsustainable) deficit. Oh, and by then the debt will be a lot more than $15 trillion by then. 

And that's just the "return to normal" scenario. What if the exploding euro leads bond investors to wake up that all debt of highly-indebted, sclerotic-growth, perpetual-deficit, can't-cure-runaway-entitlement governments is dubious?  Greece didn't get in trouble trying to borrow for one year -- it got in trouble trying to roll over debt. If that moment comes and the US has lots of long-term debt outstanding, it just means a mark-to-market loss for bondholders. If we are rolling over short term debt, then the debt crisis comes to the US. And there is no Germany to bail us out.


Notice how the 30 year rate plummets in 2011 and remains low. And this is on indexed debt, not just reflecting low inflation expectations! Cochrane's refinancing ideas would allow taxpayers to pay these low coupon rates for 30 years into the future, potentially saving trillions in interest costs. 
Todd goes beyond the usual 30 year Treasuries, and advocates 50 or 100 year Treasuries. Good idea! I have wilder ideas. We should think about bonds with no principal repayment at all. 30 years of coupons, or even perpetuities. These bonds never have to be rolled over -- you never have to issue new debt to pay off the principal of the old debt. Or, if we want to maximize the duration of the bonds, issue the opposite: zero-coupon 50 year bonds.  At least that puts off any problems for 50 years!  If restructuring physical debt is hard, do what the private sector does: Massive fixed-for-floating swaps could lengthen the US maturity structure very quickly without unsettling somewhat illiquid markets for seasoned bonds. 

Lots of smart money is locking in absurdly low rates. Why not the US?"

Tuesday, September 4, 2012

Where does Federal Spending Go?

An illuminating chart I've had packed away that I've been meaning to share. It shows real per-capita Federal spending by sector over time, with interesting implications.

Basically, Federal spending has been steady in all discretiony sectors, while the cost of entitlements has gone through the proverbial roof. And on a positive note, I am at least glad that the national political discourse seems to be centered on this fact and the debate of the Presidential election framed around its  implications. 

Sunday, July 22, 2012

"You Didn't Build That"

I haven't delved much into the political cycle of the United States, and won't. And let me preface this post by saying I support public investment projects that have a rate of return higher than the interest rate on the bonds needed to fund them. But there's been a lot of discussion in the Presidential race about the role of government vs business, ect. I'll comment on this from time to time, sometimes on one side sometimes the other. So here goes round one.

The fact is that the potency of the public sector depends on that of the private sector, not the other way around. If the government "builds" a bridge it contracts the construction work to a private firm; the quality and cost of the bridge will be a function of the capital, labor, and technology that firm can devote to the project. The government effectively just moved money from taxpayers to the contracting firm.


Moreover, this pattern holds through history; The Federal government, in effect, didn't win the Civil War; Colt and Winchester, the textile mills of New England, and the iron forges of Pennsylvannia did. At times, goverment has directed these private resources to (very) productive ends, such as the Interstate Highway System or the internet.

Today, Microsoft, IBM, Lockheed Martin, Boeing, Arcelor Mittal, et al. allow Uncle Sam to conduct his business, both here and abroad. I guess the message is that it's private productivity that leads to high quality public projects, not the other way around.